When it comes to the garden, leave it to the worms to be some of the hardest workers. While you may plant a few seeds and occasionally water, it’s the worms that are putting in the long hours and sleepless nights to ensure you have a fruitful crop.
Worms are great at composting too and can reduce the amount of work needed to turn your kitchen scraps into valuable fertilizer. But with so many worms out there, which one should you choose? Here we look at the main differences between red wiggler vs earthworm and which ones are best for composting.
Table of Contents
Worms In The Garden
Worms are crucial to a garden’s health. They perform many specialized functions that keep our soil healthy and help our plants to thrive. Between red wrigglers and earthworms, you have a complete team of willing laborers that will help you get many of the more unpleasant garden tasks done without you having to lift a finger.
One of these worms is an excellent digger, capable of burrowing to depths of 6 feet or more! They tunnel ceaselessly through your garden bed, aerating the soil, its beneficial microorganisms, and all your plant’s roots. The other is a voracious eater of kitchen scraps and other organic waste. It can eat half of its weight in food each day and transmute it into organic fertilizer in a process known as vermicomposting.
Although it can be tough to tell them apart from looks alone, with a little worm knowledge you’ll be picking the right worm for your gardening needs in no time.
Common Earthworms: The Nightcrawler
After a rainstorm, you may notice that your yard is filled with common earthworms. Also known as nightcrawlers, this species of reddish-brown worms (Lumbricus terrestris) is well-known for being able diggers and eating dirt as they go along.
They get all the nutrition they need from the soil, leaving behind highly-fertile “castings” that help feed your plants. Their deep tunnels also bring air down into the soil, oxygenating plant roots and the microorganism that help to keep your soil healthy.
They tend to be more solitary and burrow up to half a foot underground. Not only can you collect them from your yard after the rain, but due to their large size, these are also the type of worm that is4h’ most commonly available from bait shops.
Here are some theories as to why earthworms come up during a rainstorm:
- Earthworms get oxygen through their skin, and when their tunnels fill up with rainwater they need to come to the surface to be able to breathe.
- They are able to more easily find each other and mate when they all emerge to the surface.
- The moist surface allows them to move much faster, giving them the opportunity to travel greater distances during the rain.
These segmented worms can appear very similar to earthworms, but are usually smaller and have a red-purple hue to their skin.
The diet and behavior of red wigglers (Eisenia fetida) make them a great addition to a compost pile. Unlike nightcrawlers, they prefer to eat manure and decaying plant matter and will literally eat all your kitchens scraps.
Red wigglers can tolerate higher temperatures and tend to live closer to the surface in larger groups. They’re capable reproducing quickly and can form large populations in a matter of months.
Which Worms Do Best in a Compost Pile?
While both red wigglers and nightcrawlers are invaluable to gardeners everywhere, only red wigglers really belong in a compost pile. Unlike earthworms, red wigglers actually eat rotting organic material from the surface of the soil while earthworms eat already-composted soil that’s deep underground.
What this means for you is that if you stock a compost bid with red wigglers, you can simply put all your kitchen scraps and other plant matter right on the surface and the worms will come up to eat it. You also don’t have to worry about turning your compost, since these worms will eat from the top and spread their castings throughout the bin. Earthworms will, unfortunately, die in a worm compost bin from lack of food.
Compost piles can get hot. All those organisms working together to break down your kitchen scraps can produce a lot of heat, which in turn keeps the process going. Earthworms, however, don’t do well in hot environments and can actually hurt themselves as they try to get away from the heat. They’ll dig deeper and deeper, trying to find a way out of your compost bin, only to crash against a sealed bottom. Red wigglers do just fine in the heat and like to stay the surface of your bin.
Vermicomposting with red wigglers will also produce usable compost much faster other methods. You won’t have to wait for the plant matter to decompose on its own before heat and microorganism break it down. Your worms will take care of the whole process for you, giving you usable compost in three to six months.
How Many Red Wigglers Do I Need?
The number of compost worms you start out with depends on the size of your compost bin and the amount of food waste you need to be composted. Red wigglers can compost about half their body weight each day, meaning a pound of worms will compost around half a pound of food daily. If a pound of worms sounds like a lot, that’s because it is! It’s roughly 800-1000 worms!
Measuring how much food waste your family is producing daily will give you a rough idea as to how many worms you’ll need. If you notice the food isn’t being eaten quickly enough, cut back on how much you’re giving them or add more worms. If they’re devouring your food faster than you can produce scraps, take some worms out and share with friends.
Now that you’ve learned the differences between red wiggler vs earthworm and which ones do best in your compost bin, it’s time to get composting! You can usually get red wigglers at your local nursery or online, and a pound can cost anywhere between $20-$30. If 1000 worms sound like too much, start small. They’ll reproduce quickly and soon you’ll have all the worms you need.
Don’t forget to pin it！
9 thoughts on “Red Wiggler vs Earthworm: Which Worm is Best For Composting”
I have never deliberately stocked my composter with red wigglers, but I have worms in there that seem to fit the bill. Is it possible that they colonized it on their own? I live in Canada.
Yeah, Dave … that’s my question, too. I’m in upstate NY and have experienced the same thing.
We bought red wigglers at the bait store for our bin. Are they the same?
How much? please
If your compost bin is open, they will colonize.
I used an old plastic bin and started to throw dry leaves, yard clippings, soil, fruit and veggies leftovers, and the earthworms just took over the bin. I turn the dirt around every other day when I throw some food scraps, and it is looking good after almost a year. I don’t know if I should try to compost with these red wigglers.
I have a theory, dear internet, please bunk or confirm.
I keep a vermiculture in my kitchen (cupboard under the sink). It is rather small, and working splendidly (no smell!). What I have are mostly red wigglers, and their colony is thriving, how ever, as the reason behing my worm bin is not in getting fertilizers or getting rid of the foodscrabs, but to keep them as a staple food source to our pets (axolotls), and night crawlers would be preferred, or considered more delicious by the animal than red wigglers, I was thinking, that if I’d add an extra layer on my bin (it is currently two-storey, holes at the bottom of the top box to get the worm juice leak to the bottom). Would the nightcrawlers be able to survive in the soil, that’s mostly soil, having the red wiggler worm juice running through it offering nutrients, but not adding the any food stuff on that layer? Am I at all on the right track assuming, that the red wiggler excrements are what nightcrawlers would in turn like to eat?
Red wrigglers is better in such a way that you need not turn your compost on a regular basis. Red wrigglers can feed close to the surface.
In Ottawa, Eisenia fetida have to be kept inside over the winter in vermicomposters, they die with even the lightest frost. Our common earthworms go deep enough in winter that they survive and spring back into action as soon as the weather warms up.